Learn

Dealing with Trees with Surface Roots

If you have large-growing trees in your yard, you might find yourself having to deal with surface roots. Surface roots are problematic because they make lawn maintenance challenging underneath shade trees. Additionally, large tree roots become a trip hazard. They can also disrupt sidewalks, causing them to crack. Finally, they’re just unsightly! So, how do you deal with surface roots without jeopardizing the health of your tree? What actually causes them? We’ll answer these questions and more!

What Causes Surface Rooting?

surface roots-2Some trees are simply predisposed to having shallow roots. This includes Norway Maples, Red Maples, Silver Maples, Willows, aspens, Pin Oaks, and Beeches. And any large tree can develop surface roots after a certain age. It’s just how they grow. Still, other factors play a part.

Poor soil quality

For the most part, the majority of trees’ roots are found within the top 12 inches of soil. Contrary to popular belief, tree roots usually do not grow very deep unless they are in loose and sandy soil. Surface rooting is most common in compacted or clay-based soil often found in urban areas. When the roots within the first few inches of soil get large enough, they break through the surface. Gradually, rain and wind erode the soil around them, further exposing them. 

Lack of oxygen

Roots need oxygen. In compacted soil, they must grow up to the surface in order to get enough oxygen to keep the tree alive. In many cases, trees with surface roots are struggling to breathe and are doing their best to adapt to an environment that is less than ideal.  

So, What can i do to deal with surface roots?

 

If you have a tree or trees with surface roots, there are a couple of things you can do. 

Don’t cut roots!

Don’t cut the offending roots, no matter how tempting it is. Cutting them can provide an easy entry point for diseases and harmful insects. It can also negatively impact a tree’s stability, making it more likely to fall over in a bad storm. Finally, cutting roots can kill thousands of tiny “feeder roots” that allow the tree to absorb water and nutrients. This can lead to dieback in the canopy or complete death of the tree. 

Topdress around the base of the tree

To help deal with surface roots, mix equal parts topsoil and compost. Then, apply two inches of the mixture around the base of the tree. Sow the area in late summer with shade-tolerant grass seed, keeping it well-watered. If the roots are still prominent within a year, you can add another two inches of the mixture and reseed. Never add more than four inches of soil to the area beneath an existing tree! Otherwise, you risk suffocating it.

Instead of grass, you could plant drought-tolerant groundcover under the tree. This would save you the trouble of having to mow in that area—or, you could mimic nature and consider using moss as groundcover!

Use mulch!

Your best bet is to put down four inches of mulch—preferably wood chips—underneath the tree. This will help level out the area while keeping roots cool and moist and allowing them to breathe. Don’t put down more than four inches, though, and don’t pile mulch against the trunk. 

Avoid trees with shallow root systems

If you have compact or clay soil, your tree will inevitably have some surface roots. Still, some trees are way more likely to develop them than others. Steer clear of notorious surface rooters like aspens, beeches, river birches, certain maples (red, silver, sugar, Freeman, and Norway), pin oaks, spruces, sweetgums, tulip poplars, and willows. These trees have inherently more shallow roots and are more likely to pose a problem in your landscape. 

Choose trees with deeper root systems

Some trees have deeper root systems. These trees will make much better options in your landscape and are way less likely to develop surface roots. Black gum, blue atlas cedar, ginkgo, golden rain tree, horse chestnut, certain oak varieties (red, Regal Prince®, swamp white, white, and willow), planetree, yellowwood, and zelkova are some of the best options. 

Consider a smaller tree

Trees that mature at under 30 feet tall will usually not have roots large enough to cause major problems. If size is not as important to you, consider varieties like cherry trees, dogwoods, magnolias, mimosas, Japanese maples, paperbark maples, redbuds, and lilac trees, just to name a few. 

Don’t plant your tree too deep

Planting your tree deep within the soil won’t actually prevent surface roots. On the contrary—we actually recommend planting trees two inches above grade (but make sure the rootball isn’t exposed, or it could dry out and be more vulnerable to winter damage). 

Give trees room to grow

Give your tree space if there is pavement nearby. Large-growing tree should be planted at least six feet away from paved surfaces. If you want to plant your tree between a sidewalk and a street, make sure the planting spot is at least eight feet wide with no utility lines overhead. Otherwise, choose a smaller variety. Keep in mind: some cities have restrictions and specific guidelines on planting, so you’ll want to check with your local forestry department before planting.

26 Comments

  • Debra says:

    If the exposed surface routes are starting to hollow out is that a sign that the tree is dying and needs cut down? I’m always worried when we have heavy winds that the tree is going to fall on our house. It is a silver maple. I don’t want to remove it but will if there is a high likelihood it will fall down

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hi Debra!

    Silver Maples are famous for exposed roots and while they can be long lived Trees, they are also notorious for wind damage and weakening structure over time. With that being said, we understand the desire not to give up on your Tree.

    If you are able, please send some photos to us and we will share with our Growers. Or, if you prefer, we can have one of our Growers talk you through what might be best for your Tree. Many times, for a mature Silver Maple, a strong pruning could be beneficial and extend the useful life of the Tree. We do not believe the issue with the roots you are seeing is an indication of failure.

    A professional pruning will reduce chance of wind damage. Another consideration may be to plant a replacement Tree(s) nearby and begin to plan for the eventual replacement that will be required. Again, any photos you can send of your property will allow us to guide you on this.

    Thank you for your question and we look forward to encouraging you through this Tree challenge!

  • Corinne says:

    September 2017

    Hi, we planted a silver maple tree about 15 years ago in our backyard. We planted it too close to our house, not realizing how quickly it would grow. The closest point to our house is 13 1/2 feet. We are concerned that the roots will do damage to our foundation, etc. We are not on a septic system. We have noticed that the majority of the surface roots, which are getting quite big, are growing on the back side of the tree, away from the house where there is more room to grow. Large tree roots are not visible above ground in the direction of our house. Should we consider cutting the tree before it damages our foundation? I love this tree and hate the thought of cutting it down but will if it is likely to do damage. Thanks for your reply.

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hi Corinne,

    Thank you for reaching out!

    I’m afraid, in this case, you are worried about the wrong end of the Tree!

    Roots will grow until they reach a barrier, they will then reroute. They won’t grow into your foundation unless there is a crack into which they can grow.

    The problem here is that Silver Maples have what we call ‘weak wood’. At this age, it may not be something you really have to worry about but within ten years, you should. Your Tree will begin to drop branches or if a strong storm comes through, it will cause them to fall.

    The question you need to ask yourself is – do you want to wait for something to happen in ten years or be ahead of the game?

    If you choose to remove the Tree, you should consider the Autumn Blaze Maple as a replacement. This one in particular is a hybrid – its ‘mom’ is the Red Maple and its ‘dad’ is the Silver Maple. It has the vigor and growth rate from the Silver Maple but not the issues with weak wood. It truly is a fantastic Tree!

    Let us know if you have any other questions! Our Growers are available to help you out in any way possible!

    Thank you & enjoy your day!

  • Debra Silver says:

    I am getting a hole in the center of my crapemyrtle tree where the branches start. I don’t want it to rot or get insects/critters there. What should I do. My tree is 40 plus years old. I love this tree….help (Southern Belle from NC)!!

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hi Debra!

    Thank you for contacting Bower & Branch!

    We understand your love for Crape Myrtles and in your neck of the woods, I would imagine they are spectacular!

    I’m afraid I may not have to most encouraging news for you. Crape Myrtles are not considered to be a multi-generational Tree – your Tree is entering its ‘Golden Years’.

    We don’t believe any treatment or ‘surgery’ could prevent the inevitable at this point. If you are able to maintain optimal conditions (supplemental watering, fresh mulch bed, etc.), you may be able to enjoy your Crape Myrtle for another ten years or so.

    I am very sorry we don’t have a better diagnoses for you. If you have any other questions, feel free to email us at customercare@bowerandbranch.com, Live Chat with us on our site or call us at 866-873-3888.

    Thank you & enjoy your day!

  • Penelope says:

    We have a very large Zelkova tree approximately 15 feet from our house. It’s likely 80 feet tall and 60 years old. We found one root growing along the length of the foundation (~1.5 foot deep). That root was about the size of an adult wrist. We cut that root because we think it is the reason a foundation crack has started leaking. The soil here is clay. I’m trying to figure out if I should dig all the way down to the bottom of the foundation to look for more roots. Would it be reasonable to expect there to be deeper roots of similar or larger size also growing in the same area?

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hello Penelope!

    Great question!

    Tree roots actually grow out (not down), only a foot or two below the surface, so the chance of there being large roots at the base of your foundation is very low.

    Now, you may have done damage to the Tree when you cut the root. You won’t see the resulting damage until next year, as the temperatures rise and the Tree begins to ‘stress’. We recommend that you supplement with water as we go into Summer to make sure your Tree has plenty in order to push through the shock from the cut. You may see some die back in the canopy as a result.

    We would also suggest that you not cut any more roots unless a Certified Arborist has determined it must be done. You could possibly kill your Tree by cutting the roots or weaken the stability of it, making it more susceptible to blowing over in a storm.

    If you have any other questions, feel free to email us at grower@bowerandbranch.com – our staff of Growers are here to answer any questions you may have!

    Thank you & enjoy your day!

  • Mark Hubbell says:

    My daughter has a Norway maple about ten feet from the house. It was there when she bought it last year. I am concerned about branches on the roof and roots in the foundation. And it is already surface rooting though it’s probably only about 15 years old. I am thinking it should be removed and another tree planted further from the house. What do you recommend? Thank you!

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hello Mark,

    Thank you for contacting Bower & Branch!

    I am sorry to say that we agree with you on your concerns.

    The Norway Maple is a fast growing, aggressive Tree that can be between 40-50′ tall and 30-50′ wide when mature. It is known for its shallow root system and dense branching – both which inhibit anything from growing underneath it.

    You should definitely be concerned about branches falling onto the house and somewhat concerned with the foundation.

    It would be best if the Tree were removed now and a new one planted. The longer you wait, the more expensive it may become. Depending on what variety of Tree she decides to go with, she may not have to plant it in a new location. There are some Trees that stay on the ‘skinny’ side, she could go with one of those!

    If she needs any help deciding on a new Tree for her new home, we would love to help her out! She can give us a call at 866-873-3888, live chat with us or find her perfect match!

    Let us know if you have any other questions – we are here to help =)

    Thank you!

  • Tam says:

    I have a 5 year old river birch about 10 feet from both my and my neighbors house. They have begun complaining about the surface roots and keep nagging me to axe them although I have explained that the tree will likely fall on one of our houses next time it storms if I do that (we live in NC and get 30 to 40 mile per hour wind gusts with big storms). Is there any reason to believe the roots of a river birch will go under a foundation and damage it?

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hello Tam – thank you for your question!

    As River Birches are a large, fast growing Tree (50′ tall by 30′ wide), they do typically have surface roots. You should expect to see surface roots continue to appear. Please don’t take an axe to them! This will damage the Tree significantly and lead to failure down the road.

    The roots of a River Birch are not likely to cause damage to a solid foundation. However, if there are existing faults in the foundations (cracks), the roots could add to that damage over a number of years.

    Overall, we are unable to say with certainty that your Tree will not cause issues to either yours or your neighbor’s foundations. We are sorry about that!

    If you have any other questions, feel free to live chat with us on the site, email us at grower@bowerandbranch.com or give us a call at 866-873-3888.

    Thank you =)

  • Kyle says:

    I live near Charlotte, NC and I have a 10 year old Maple Tree in my front yard. Several of its surface roots were getting close to our foundation and sidewalk – I think I made a terrible mistake before doing research online.

    The tree appears to have 7-8 surface roots from what I can see and I just cut off 4 of them about 2 feet from the base of the tree yesterday. 2 of the roots were approx. 4 inches in diameter and the tree is about 15 feet tall with a diameter of 6.3 inches about 4 feet from the base of the tree.

    Please tell me I just didn’t kill my tree? Like many others, I thought the tree had deeper main roots and I was just cutting a few surface roots to protect my sidewalk and possibly foundation. After I did it, my wife read online about what a terrible mistake I might have done. So I’m in desperate need of advice (and/or encouragement if the tree can survive this).

    Is there anything I can do so my tree survives? Please, any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hi Kyle,

    Thank you for contacting Bower & Branch!

    We’ve discussed your situation with our Growers and we may be able to give you a little hope.

    By cutting off those roots, you have done serious damage to your Tree but there is a good chance the Maple can survive this. Your Tree will be set back for several years and you may see it defoliate a little now as a response to the damage. You may also see it ‘color up’ earlier this Fall compared to other Trees.

    Here is what we recommend you do to help your Tree grow through this now:

    – You need to water slowly and thoroughly, twice a month now through October and then once in November. You should do this every two weeks by bringing your hose to the base of your Tree and leaving it on a slow trickle for two hours each time.

    – Apply our Elements Organic Fertilizer in a granular form over the root zone (all the soil beneath the canopy) in October immediately before watering.

    Next Year:

    – Begin your bimonthly watering regimen next June and continue through September.

    – Apply more Elements Organic Fertilizer next May.

    With a little TLC, your Tree may grow through this but it will experience a bit of a set back. Just keep up with the TLC and you should see your Tree bounce back!

    Let us know if you’ve got any other questions!

    Thank you & good luck!

  • Robert LeMere says:

    My 88 yr. old neighbor has a beautiful Pin Oak, trunk is about 18-24″ and roots at the base growing about 2′ out from the trunk and 12″ to 18″ above the ground. Is this a serious problem?

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hello Robert,

    Thank you for contacting Bower & Branch!

    No, we wouldn’t necessarily say that this is a serious problem.

    What mildly concerns us is the height at which the roots are presenting – 12-18” – that seems a bit odd. This leads us to believe that there may be some sort of erosion issue occurring. If that is the case, we would recommend applying a layer of mulch to help combat the issue.

    Let us know if you have any other questions about your neighbor’s Pin Oak =)

    Thank you & good luck!

  • Carrie Rickwood says:

    We have a very large Norwegian Maple approx 10ft from our house. We are wanting to put in a patio but to do so we will need to cut some roots and place down a root barrier. I don’t want to hurt the tree and was wondering if it’s ok to cut approx. 4 roots? The cut would be approx 6ft from the tree and the width of the biggest root is 1 3/4″. The diameter of the tree is approx 7ft. If anyone could offer advice it would be much appreciated. Thanks.

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hello Carrie,

    Thank you for reaching out!

    I’m afraid that the sort of cut you are talking about IS going to be detrimental to your Tree. The roots you want to cut are what we call the structural roots. They are the roots that prevent your Tree from falling over. By removing a portion of them, you are causing the Tree to be unstable and are opening yourself up to failure down the road. If a strong storm comes through with high winds, you could be dealing with a serious problem.

    When cutting the structural roots, you will also be cutting the feeder roots (the small fibrous roots) – which, as you can imagine, disrupts how the Tree is able to feed itself.

    The damage that occurs by cutting these roots may not be reflected immediately – they may present over time. Early defoliation, dying branches and stunted growth are all visual signs of damage. You will also be opening your Tree up to diseases and pests that feed on weakened Trees.

    Truthfully, my Growers recommend that you either cut the Tree down or move the location of the patio before cutting the roots of your Tree.

    I’m very sorry that I don’t have better news for you when it comes to your Tree. We hate to recommend removal as we love Trees but I’m afraid in your situation, it may be necessary.

    If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to let us know! We are here to help!

    Thank you & good luck!

  • OhNoJoe says:

    I have a 90 foot Oak tree (I’m lying but it’s big) with an exposed 4 inch wide root pretty close to the base of the tree. Let’s just say some knucklehead who was trying to avoid some newly planted flowers with the lawn tractor ran over the root after being careful for about 10 years. The tractor, which was just doing its job, sliced the top of the root removing the bark (or bark like skin) and exposing the lighter wood under the bark (phloem?). However, the tree did get its lick in causing the tractor’s blades to be damaged beyond repair. We live in the woods, literally. We have a pretty small lawn and this tree is very close to the house (it’s really just a shack), the propane tank, two sheds and some other big trees then the woods. We recently have lost a number older trees up by the road and the tree guy, not an Arborist, told me that one of the trees got sick and then was domino effect. My question is what do I do now. Should I put tar on the wound like the old days, cover the root with mulch or what?

  • Wendi-Jo says:

    Hello OhNoJoe!

    First things first, you certainly have a way with words! You got quite a few chuckles out of our staff here with your tale =)

    As for your Oak Tree and what to do – our Team recommends letting nature take it from here. Putting tar (yuck!) on it or covering it with mulch will inhibit healing, it’s best to let it heal on its own. Your Tree is well established and this wound may not be as detrimental as you may think.

    One recommendation we do have for you is to make sure that the bark that has been damaged is a clean cut as opposed to a ragged edge. If the edges are ragged, simply take a little pocket knife and clean them up a bit.

    We also recommend that you fertilize your Tree this Fall – preferably with our Bower & Branch Elements Organic Fertilizer – as your Tree may need a little help to bouce back.

    Let us know if you have any other questions or concerns about your Oak Tree =) We are here to help!

    Good luck!

  • Akshay says:

    I have planted a 3.5 gallon Silver Maple tree in my backyard at about 25 feet away from my house. It is of 1 inch diameter stem and roughly 10 feet high. Should I be worried about its shallow root system and remove it? It was just planted yesterday.

    Thank you
    Akshay

  • Wendi-Jo - Plant Whisperer says:

    Hello Akshay,

    Thank you for your question!

    To be truthful, yes, you should be concerned – but not only for that reason. There are many different reasons we would recommend removal.

    This Tree is very fast growing and can put on more than 24” of growth a year. Fast growing Trees tend to have shallow, aggressive roots which cause issues as they grow – specifically, Silver Maple roots have been known to lift sidewalks and break macadam driveways. Silver Maples have a mature width between 40-60′ and their roots can extend beyond that. So the possible damage and surface rooting is far spreading.

    On top of all of that, the wood is weak and brittle. As a result, during severe storms, you can expect branches to break off of the Tree.

    Unfortunately, we would recommend removal of your Silver Maple as the negatives outweigh the positives.

    If you were looking for something similar, we would suggest the Autumn Blaze Maple – this is a cross between the native Red Maple and the Silver Maple. The Autumn Blaze has inherited all the ‘good’ from the Silver Maple, leaving the bad far behind!

    I’m sorry we don’t have better news for you! If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to let us know!

    Thank you & good luck!

  • Cyndi Adamec says:

    We have a 5-6 year old Mountain Ash tree in our front yard. It gets full sun and plenty of water, but every time we get any winds, the tree practically gets uprooted. During high winds we have to tie it down. When it isn’t windy, we take the ties off. Is there something we can do to make it more rooted? We live in central Michigan.

  • Wendi-Jo - Plant Whisperer says:

    Hello Cyndi,

    Thank you for your question!

    After reviewing your situation with our Growers, they believe you have the European Mountain Ash variety. Unfortunately, that variety is notoriously weak rooted.

    Chances are, based off of your location, your soil is either a heavy clay soil or very sandy soil – both of those are not very conducive to root growth.

    I’m afraid there is no ‘magic solution’ that will make your issue go away but we have an idea for something that may help. What my Growers recommend you do is to stake your Tree with three 2” thick metal pipes. You are going to want to get them in the ground as deep as you can – make sure there is no wiggling from those poles. When you attach the poles to your Tree, you will want to make sure there is some wiggle room there. Allowing your Tree to move a little in the wind will encourage root growth in order to stabilize the Tree.

    We would also recommend that you fertilize with the Bower & Branch Organic Elements Fertilizer – our product is designed to build a strong soil environment, which will increase the availability of nutrients and the ability of the Tree to use them.

    Let us know if you have any other questions – we wish you luck!

    Thank you =)

  • Mary Link says:

    We have an October Glory Maple tree that we planted in 2007. We live in the Sacramento, California area. We are noticing roots in our lawn and we are concerned that the roots may damage our rock courtyard. The roots seem to be encircling our water drainage pipe. We do have hard pan/clay soil. It was planted on a mound and is approximately 10 feet from the edge of the courtyard. It is a beautiful tree and provides a lot of shade. It is approximately 30-40 feet tall and is 34” in diameter about 2 feet from the base.
    Thank you in advance for your advice re: this beautiful tree.

  • Wendi-Jo - Plant Whisperer says:

    Hello Mary,

    Thank you for contacting Bower & Branch about your surface roots!

    My Growers believe you may have asked this question at JUST the right time for your courtyard! Based on the information that you have provided, removing the roots about 10-12′ away from your Tree should be safe. Our Growers recommend taking action now in order to avoid any future concerns.

    Specifically, we recommend contacting a professional arborist that will be able to provide on site expertise. Bower & Branch recommends Davey Tree Experts for these challenges. We urge you to contact them and invest your efforts in solving this problem today. We believe some simple root pruning is proper and doable at this stage. Your Tree sounds beautiful and completely worth the effort!

    Good luck =)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *